Bayesian Estimation of Spatio-Temporal Models with Covariates Measured with Spatio-Temporally Correlated Errors: Evidence from Monte Carlo Simulation


  • Mohammad Masjkur Institut Pertanian Bogor
  • Henk Folmer University of Groningen


Spatio-temporal data are susceptible to covariates measured with errors. However, little is known about the empirical effects of measurement error on the asymptotic biases in regression coefficients and variance components when measurement error is ignored. The purpose of this paper is to analyze Bayesian inference of spatio-temporal models in the case of a spatio-temporally correlated covariate measured with error by way of Monte Carlo simulation. We consider spatio-temporal model with spatio-temporal correlation structure corresponds to the Leroux conditional autoregressive (CAR) and the first order autoregressive priors. We apply different spatio-temporal dependence parameter of response and covariate. We use the relative bias (RelBias) and Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE) as valuation criteria. The simulation results show the Bayesian analysis considering measurement error show more accurate and efficient estimated regression coefficient and variance components compared with naïve analysis.


L. Anselin,. Spatial Econometrics. A Companion to Theoretical

Econometrics. Edited by Badi H. Baltagi. Blackwell

Publishing Ltd, 2003.

J. P. LeSage, 2014. Spatial econometrics panel data model

specification: A Bayesian approach. Spatial Statistics, 9,


L. Bernardinelli, C. Pascutto, N. G. Best, and W. R. Gilks.

Disease mapping with errors in covariates. Statist.

Medicine, 16, 741-752.

Y. Li, H. Tang, X. Lin, 2009. Spatial linear mixed models

with covariate measurement errors. Statistica Sinica 19(3):

Huque, M. H., H.D Bondell, and L. Ryan. 2014. On the impact

of covariate measurement error on spatial regression

modelling. Environmetrics 25:560-570.

Muff, S., A. Riebler, L. Held, H. Rue, and P. Saner. 2015.

Bayesian analysis of measurement error models using integrated

nested Laplace approximations. J. R. Stat. Soc. Ser. C.

Appl. Stat. 64 (2): 231-252.

Stoklosa J., P. Dann, R. M. Huggins and W. H. Hwang. 2016.

Estimation of survival and capture probabilities in open population

capture-recapture models when covariates are subject

to measurement error. Computational Statistics and Data

Analysis 96, 74-86.

Huque, M. H., H.D. Bondell, R. J. Carroll and L. Ryan. 2016.

Spatial regression with covariate measurement error: A

semiparametric approach. Biometrics:1-9.

Xia, H. and B. P Carlin. 1998. Spatio-temporal models with

errors in covariates: mapping Ohio lung cancer mortality.

Statist. Medicine 17, 2025-2043.

Rushworth A., D. Lee and R. Mitchell. 2014. A spatio-temporal

model for estimating the long-term effects of air

pollution on respiratory hospital admissions in Greater London.

Spatial and Spatio-temporal Epidemiology 10:29-38.

Truong L. T., L. Kieu and T. A. Vu. 2016. Spatio-temporal

and random parameter panel data models of traffic crash fatalities

in Vietnam. Accident Analysis and Prevention


Gelman, A., Carlin J. B., Stern H. S., Dunson D. B., Vehtari A,

and Rubin, D.B., Bayesian Data Analysis. Chapman &

Hall/CRC, New York, NY, 2014.